Blog Layout

Innocent Spouse Relief – Husband Had No Knowledge of Wife’s Embezzlement Scheme

Aug 08, 2018

by Gregory S. Dowell

August 8, 2018


As a general rule, married taxpayers who file a joint income tax return are jointly and severally liable for the tax reported on the return. This is an example of the long reach of the IRS to perfect the government’s claim and to demand payment for income taxes from the married couple, collectively and individually. This general rule is a good reason why anyone signing an income tax return should have reasonable knowledge about what is on the tax return.


However, in some situations the IRS acknowledges that an individual can be unfairly harmed by the deceit of their spouse. Internal Revenue Code Section 6015(b)(1) provides that a taxpayer who files a joint return can be relieved of the liability for an understatement of tax if the spouse can establish that he or she did not know that there was an understatement, and it would be unfair to hold the “innocent” spouse liable.  To invoke this relief, the innocent spouse has to make the election within two years after the date the IRS begins collection actions. An election to be treated as an innocent spouse treats each spouse as if they filed a separate return, and the separate spouses are responsible for the tax on their separate returns.


In a recent Tax Court Memorandum (2018-115), the Tax Court allowed innocent spouse relief to a husband, who earned a living as a machine operator in a factory, and also worked as a home inspector. The wife was an accountant who had embezzled funds from her employer – not surprisingly, the embezzled funds were not reported on the couple’s tax return as income. The wife handled the family’s finances, and she also handled the depositing of the checks from the husband’s home inspection business.  At tax time, husband gave all of his records to his wife, who then provided all of the records to the paid preparer. The husband did not inspect or look at any of the bank or credit card records. Over several years, the wife embezzled funds from her employer, which was a blood bank, to the tune of about $458,000. During that period, no lavish expenditures were made; the couple did not pay off their mortgage and the husband continued to drive the same car. The husband was able to prove to the Tax Court that he had no knowledge of his wife’s embezzlement until she was arrested in June of 2011. In making the determination, the Tax Court considered the husband’s occupation, his education, the fact that his wife was an accountant, and that he had no interaction with the family’s finances.


In reviewing the case, the Tax Court found that the husband did not have knowledge of the embezzlement with regard to the filing of the couple’s 2010 return, but that he did have knowledge with regard to the 2011 return (she was arrested in June of 2011 and the husband provided the tax materials to the paid preparer).  Thus, innocent spouse relief was granted for 2010 but not for 2011.


This is a case rich in details and is an interesting read, as are many of these cases. The bottom line is that these cases are always based on the specific facts and circumstances. Gathering evidence and communicating the same to the IRS and, in this case, to the Tax Court, is critical.

14 Dec, 2023
With year-end approaching, it is time to start thinking about moves that may help lower your tax bill for this year and next. This year’s planning is more challenging than usual due to changes made by the Inflation Reduction Act of 2022 and the SECURE 2.0 Act.
14 Dec, 2023
With year-end approaching, it is time to start thinking about moves that may help lower your business's taxes for this year and next.
By Greg Dowell 14 Nov, 2023
How to make doing good a little less frightening financially.
By Greg Dowell 13 Nov, 2023
Catching many businesses by surprise, this Act kicks in with filing requirements as early as January 1, 2024.
By Greg Dowell 05 Sep, 2023
Having a business fail for lack of employees was unheard of 10 years ago. The problem existed for many businesses long before the pandemic, but it certainly went to a whole new level from 2020 to the present.
By Greg Dowell 24 Aug, 2023
Improve profitability, reduce the opportunity for fraud, focus on your core business, eliminate excuses for tardy financial data - what's not to love about outsourcing your accounting?
By Greg Dowell 16 Aug, 2023
ESOPs have been around for years; they could be a solution for ownership transition.
By Greg Dowell 16 May, 2023
by Gregory S. Dowell Updated May 16, 2023 Spring is the traditional kick-off to wedding season, and thoughts quickly turn to the wedding venue, gifts, the happy couple, and, of course, the guest list. Lurking somewhere in the shadows, behind even that strange uncle you barely know, is another guest that needs to be considered: The tax impact on the newlyweds. To start, newlyweds will have two options for filing their income taxes in the year of marriage: Filing status can either be married filing jointly, or married filing separately. In the vast majority of cases, a couple will benefit with a lower overall tax burden to the couple by choosing to file married filing jointly. One of the classic cases where a couple may consider filing separately is when one spouse has significant amounts of medical expenses for the year. Medical expenses are only deductible if they exceed 7.5% of adjusted gross income; using only one spouse's income may allow a deduction to be taken if filing separately, compared to losing the medical deduction entirely if both incomes are combined by filing jointly. We previously had written about the tax trap that often occurs when two people get married, resulting often in an unanticipated balance due when the first joint tax return for the couple was filed. While President Trump’s Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA), changed the dynamics somewhat, it is still worthwhile to put pen to paper before saying “I do”. Prospective spouses have the opportunity to save money by taking income tax considerations into account before tying the knot. That’s particularly true for those who plan to marry late this year or early next year. As this article explains, from the federal income tax standpoint, some individuals marrying next year may come out ahead by either deferring or accelerating income, depending on their circumstances. Others may find it to their advantage to defer a year-end marriage until next year. For some quick background, a “marriage penalty” exists whenever the tax on a couple’s joint return is more than the combined taxes each spouse would pay if they weren’t married and each filed a single or head of household income tax return. Before President Trump’s TCJA, only the 10% and 15% married filing jointly brackets were set at twice that of the singles bracket, and so the marriage penalty effect on joint filers applied in the brackets above the 15% bracket. Beginning with the 2018 tax year, however, the TCJA set the statutory tax brackets for marrieds filing jointly-through the 32% bracket-at twice the amount of the corresponding tax brackets for singles. As a result, the TCJA eliminated any tax-bracket-generated marriage penalty effect for joint filers where each spouse has roughly the same amount of taxable income-through the 32% bracket. For example, if two individuals who each have $215,950 of taxable income file as single taxpayers for 2022, each would have a tax bill of $49,335.50, for a combined total of $98,671. If they were married, their tax bill as marrieds filing jointly would be $98,671, exactly the same amount as the combined total tax they’d pay as single taxpayers. Because the 35% bracket for marrieds filing jointly isn’t twice the amount of the singles 35% bracket, the marriage penalty effect will still apply to joint filers whose income falls in the 35% bracket. Using 2022 tax tables, two single taxpayers may each have $500,000 in taxable income, for a combined total of $1,000,000, without having any of it taxed higher than 35%. However, for marrieds filing jointly, the 35% tax bracket ends at $647,850 in taxable income, and each additional dollar of taxable income taxed at 37%. Thus, where two high-earning unmarried taxpayers with substantially equal amounts of taxable income are planning for their marriage to take place either late this year or early next, it may pay from the tax viewpoint to defer the marriage until next year. As an example, if two individuals each have $539,900 of taxable income file as single taxpayers for 2023, each would have a tax bill of $162,718, for a combined total of $325,436. If they were married before the end of the year, their tax bill as marrieds filing jointly would be $334,076, or $8,640 more than the combined total tax they’d pay as single taxpayers. If only one of the prospective spouses has substantial income, marriage and the filing of a joint return may save taxes, thus resulting in a marriage bonus. The bonus is the result of two factors: 1) the tax brackets for marrieds filing jointly cover wider spans of income than the tax brackets for taxpayers as singles; and 2) the taxable income of the lower-earning individual may not push the couple’s combined income into a higher tax bracket. In such a case, it will probably be better from the tax standpoint to accelerate the marriage into this year if feasible. There are a number of other factors that should also be taken into account when determining the effect of a marriage on income taxes of the couple. As mentioned early in this post, the first decision is to verify that filing a joint return is preferred to filing separate returns. In addition, many provisions of the tax code phase out completely (or decrease partially) as adjusted gross income increases. In a perfect world, there would only be good surprises for a newlywed couple following their wedding. To avoid any unpleasant income tax surprises, we always recommend that a newlywed couple take the time to make a projection of what their income will look like when combined as a couple, and determine what the tax bill will look like, at the Federal and State levels. After all, planning ahead, communicating with each other, discussing finances, and avoiding unpleasant surprises are some of the keys to a long marriage.
By Greg Dowell 11 Mar, 2023
Don't forget a birthday, anniversary, or any of these tax filing dates . . .
By Greg Dowell 07 Feb, 2023
The IRS asks taxpayers to wait to file 1040s if they received rebate payments from their state in 2022.
More Posts
Share by: